---

There’s one thing I appreciate about Eloisa James: the humor woven between the lines. It runs through her books, sometimes declared outright, sometimes subtle, but always able to make even a torn-dress scene bearable. This book, Four Nights With the Duke, is one of my favorites by the author. Delicious to read. To start, I loved the originality of the premise. Then, the characters. Finally, the humor of this story.

In the full nineteenth century, a woman blackmails a duke into marrying her, using his father’s betrayal as her weapon of choice. That we end up happy with the happy ending is proof of Eloisa James’s skill at character and narrative construction.

Let’s take it piece by piece. We have Vander and Mia, who have known each other since childhood because his mother is his father’s lover, already delicious in itself. In her teens, the young woman, smitten with the charms of our romantic hero, dedicates a poem with erotic undertones to him. The work is discovered by Vander’s friends, and a scene of bullying follows over the author’s poetic talents. But what hurts Mia most is that the object of her poem doesn’t lift a finger to defend her.

More than ten years later, Mia shows up at Vander’s house and demands he marry her. Vander refuses, but faced with what the young woman holds in her possession, a letter proving his father’s betrayal of the king (which could cost him his title and all his wealth), he has no choice but to give in and agree to marry her.

Now the question is: what drives Mia to such a radical decision? We understand that acting villainously isn’t part of her character, that she’s desperate to have to do it. I won’t reveal the reason, and I know nothing justifies blackmail — but it’s a good reason to blackmail someone. In fact, if blackmail could be rated on a scale of 1 to 10 (only in novels, not in real life), we’re talking a 10. And no, it doesn’t imply a marriage ad eternum, just a brief six months for the young woman to settle some pending matters in her life.

Mia is careful to write out her conditions on paper and hand them to Vander, but he throws it into the fireplace that very night, irritated by the situation. Convinced that Mia remains obsessed with him since adolescence, desiring him madly, he concludes that’s why she wants to marry him. As a way to punish her, he offers her four nights of sex a year. Mia agrees, but only when she’s the one to ask for them, determined never, ever, to have to say yes to him (of course, nothing goes as planned).

The signs are there that it isn’t an overwhelming passion for him driving Mia to that radical decision, but they escape Vander entirely, furious with the situation and even more so with the physical reactions his body has in her presence. And also because he isn’t much gifted at complex analysis, let’s just say.

Now, what makes this book a must-read of the genre is that Vander is a beast. Careful, though, not in the sense of being a bad person. The duke has a code of honor. He harms no one. He protects his own. But his social life is quite limited, and horses are his passion. He hasn’t a drop of polish. No great literary culture (none, to be honest). He’s quick-tempered and has real trouble expressing himself. His sensuality isn’t sophisticated — it’s raw, hard, urgent instead. It’s through it that he manages to express what he feels. And he starts feeling a great deal for Mia.

Mia, on the other hand, is a romantic and a novelist. The two clearly have communication problems (that’s how you’d put it in the 2000s), but she too can’t resist Vander’s lustful advances, his desire for her insatiable. We watch that desire quickly turn into something more, even as Mia and Vander are slow to understand it, until circumstances force Vander to dive into himself, understand what he feels, and make Mia believe it isn’t just desire on his part. Of course, Mia is much quicker to understand her own feelings, but that’s generally the privilege of women in this kind of book. The sex scenes are accordingly unembellished, somewhat raw, but very sensual.

There are delightful characters like Chubbie, and we even get a brief return of one of Eloisa James’s most famous characters, the Duke of Villiers, as well as Thorn, his bastard son and Vander’s best friend. There are fun, fluid dialogues and, of course, a bit of action in true Eloisa James style. A book that’s a pleasure to read, and to return to after some time.

Category: Chemistry between the protagonists
Score: ★★★★★ (5/5)
Electric from the start. Vander’s crude, insatiable desire for Mia collides with his fury at being blackmailed, and watching that heat slowly curdle into real feeling — on both sides — is what carries the book.

Category: Characters
Score: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
Mia is a fully realized heroine: a secret novelist, romantic at heart, desperate but never villainous. Vander is deliberately unpolished — no charm, no literary culture, terrible with words, which makes him less conventionally appealing than the genre’s usual dukes, but it’s precisely that roughness that makes his slow unraveling feel earned.

Category: Dialogue
Score: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
Fun and fluid, with real comic timing, helped along by a strong supporting cast, the brief returns of the Duke of Villiers and Thorn add extra sparkle to the exchanges.

Category: Intimate scenes
Score: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
Raw, urgent, unembellished — sex as Vander’s only real language, since he can barely manage feelings out loud. Sensual rather than floral, and it works because it’s consistent with who he is.

Category: Prose/style
Score: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
James’s trademark humor runs through every chapter, sometimes loud, sometimes just under the surface, turning what could be a heavy premise into something genuinely delightful to read.

Category: Originality
Score: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
The blackmail setup is a familiar romance device, but the specific mechanics — the burned list of terms, the “four nights, only when she asks” bargain, the parents’ affair backstory — give it enough of a twist to feel fresh rather than recycled.

Category: Overall score
Score: ★★★★★ (5/5)
One of my favorites by this author. A delicious premise, a heroine worth rooting for, a hero who has to earn his happy ending the hard way, and humor that never lets the story get too heavy.